Posted to Beaver Island Historical Society (Facebook page) by Beaver Island Historical Society on 2019-09-24 01:04:51. Caption as posted: "Circa 1910, a view of Paradise Bay - likely by Kalkaska-based Edward L. Beebe (1871-1945), a turn-of-the-century Michigan portrait and landscape photographer who captured a number of island scenes that later became postcards. The photo was taken near today's ball park, in front of what was then a saloon and is now a private home - a building Beebe also photographed at the time. The ribs of the abandoned schooners seen here were still visible in that area of the harbor into the early 1970's."
Visual descriptionwritten by a machine · unchecked
A broad grassy shoreline slopes toward calm water, with a pale unpaved path curving across the foreground. Several people stand or walk near the shore. Two-masted sailing vessels and low boat hulls are visible across the water and along the opposite shoreline, backed by trees and scattered buildings.
A model wrote this. It was shown the image and the catalogue record together, and asked to keep them apart — what it saw is here, what the record told it is under "taken from the record" below. It is still wrong often enough to matter, about who is pictured, where, when, and what is happening. Read it as a way to find the image, never as evidence about it. If you can correct it, please do: write to michael.bommarito@gmail.com, or see how corrections work. Someone who recognises a face or a shoreline knows more than the model did.
Individual posters, credited per image
674 × 437 px · JPEG · 47 KB
Subjects and keywords
Taken from the record
Not observed in the image — supplied by the archive's own catalogue, and repeated here so the two stay distinguishable.
The archive caption dates the scene to circa 1910 and identifies it as a view of Paradise Bay, likely photographed by Edward L. Beebe. It states that the photograph was taken near the ball park, in front of a building then used as a saloon, and that ribs of abandoned schooners remained visible in the area into the early 1970s.
Could not make out
Stated rather than guessed at.
The distant boats and shoreline structures are not identifiable in detail; it is unclear whether the low hulls are abandoned wrecks or active boats.
Rights and credit
Community source, no stated terms; published non-commercially with attribution and a link to the original post.
Credit this to Individual posters, credited per image when you use it.
Why this archive publishes it. Public Facebook groups and pages run by island organisations and residents. Each item credits the poster by name and links to the original post. Removal on request.
Material goes off the web without anyone deciding that it should: a host lapses, a gallery is retired, a link stops resolving. Holding a copy — with its provenance, its checksum and its holder's terms recorded beside it — is much of why this archive exists. If you are looking for something whose original has since gone, write to michael.bommarito@gmail.com and a full-size copy of what is held here will be sent to you.
Recorded verbatim from the provenance sidecar taken at retrieval — this archive does not restate a holder's terms in its own words, does not add a restriction the holder did not state, and does not abridge one.
Provenance
- Held by
- Individual posters, credited per image
- Collection
- Community photographs — public Facebook groups and pages
- Original
- https://www.facebook.com/photo/?fbid=1228184710723149&set=pb.100063605411595.-2207520000
- Copy taken
- 2019-09-24
- Title from
- the note recorded at retrieval
The file
| Rendition | Format | Extent | Size | SHA-256 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Master | JPEG | 674 × 437 px | 47 KB | 1f76e4dae621… |
Checksums are the values recorded when each copy was taken.
Download
- Web-sized image674 × 437 · 34 KB · WebP
- The full-resolution original, from Individual posters, credited per image674 × 437 · 47 KB · JPEG
The archive holds its own copy of that file and will supply it on request; it is not re-served here, because the holder serves it better and a second copy is a second thing to go stale.
Cite this
“Posted to Beaver Island Historical Society (Facebook page) by Beaver Island Historical Society on 2019-09-24 01:04:51”. Individual posters, credited per image. Beaver Island Archive, https://beaverislandarchive.org/media/photograph/2019-09-24-1228184710723149/. copy retrieved 2019-09-24.
Built only from what the archive recorded: the names on the record, the title as recorded, the date if one was recorded, this page, and the date the copy was taken. Nothing is filled in to satisfy a citation style.